tl.gif (159 bytes) tr.gif (156 bytes)
bl.gif (158 bytes) br.gif (158 bytes)
The Electronic Theatre
home guest book articles assets forum trix offline shop online shop links
You are here » In-depth Reviews Archive » Xbox360 » Bully: Scholarship Edition
 
Hardware Manufacturers

Nintendo

Sony

Microsoft

 

tl.gif (159 bytes)
Welcome to the Electronic Articles:  In-Depth Reviews Archive
tr.gif (156 bytes)

                                                                                                                                                                                 Electronic Theatre Image

     Bully: Scholarship Edition

            RockStar Games have a penchant for attracting attention. The cynical amongst us would say that the company have created a business model around the idea that if a game attracts publicityElectronic Theatre Image for being over-the-top; it will sell, whilst the more conservative amongst us might suggest that RockStar Games simply like to produce fictional playgrounds of an adult nature with wish-fulfilment in abundance. Whatever the case may be, the games they produce sell. Even RockStar Game Presents: Table Tennis, the most unlikely of candidates, performed greater than anyone could have expected, and yet Bully, renamed Canis Canem Edit for it’s European PlayStation2 roll-out under censorship and media pressure, although easily having recouped any productions costs, could easily have been said to have performed under expectations.

            And so here we are, with Bully: Scholarship Edition for the Xbox360 (also being simultaneously released on Wii). A concession to the title’s underperformance at retail? Or perhaps simply a wish on behalf of it’s developers to widen the title’s potential audience, and have more people play their game? Whatever the reason, Bully: Scholarship Edition is fundamentally the same game that launched on PlayStation2 in 2006.

            A Third-Person Action-Adventure title, set in the sandbox of Bullworth Academy and the surrounding town, with a host of unwelcoming characters and a taste for the uncomfortable, Bully: Scholarship Edition has all the hallmarks of a more traditional RockStar Games release. Where in which the original had been criticised for allowing people – especially children – to enact the role of a bully at school, the point had clearly been missed. Assuming the role of the extremely troubled Jimmy Hopkins, the players’ main goals begin as that of a peacekeeper, defending nerds from bullies and running errands. It’s only as the story rolls-on does the player become forced in a merciless agenda, and even then, it’s with good, moral intentions.

            The Missions in the title roll-through five Chapters – each progressing through the school year – and guide you along an inviting, if well-trodden, storyline. The Missions vary from a wide range of tasks, such as getting to places, beating bosses, outwitting nerds and many more. Each begins with a Cut-Scene explaining the activity and all have been well realised. Most Missions are limited by the in-game clock – to which the player is at all times held hostage. If in bed by 2am, Jimmy will awake at 8:30am without fail. However, Jimmy will pass-out immediately at 2am should you not Electronic Theatre Imagemake it, and things begin to get hazy around 1:30am. Also, the area – both school and town – is patrolled by Prefects, Police, Teachers and various other nasties that want to keep you down. Get caught by one of these and your Mission will end, and should a Lesson be in progress, you will immediately be forced to take it.

            Lessons in the title are presented as Mini-Games. Dissections for Biology, rhythm puzzles for Chemistry and Music, word puzzles for English and basic Maths solutions for, well, Maths. Each of these is entertaining and is a well presented use of the subject matter; it’s clear that no aspect of the environment has been ill-considered. The animation is everything; RockStar Games’ Bully: Scholarship Edition isn’t without flaws – far from it – but it’s a larger than life world. Jimmy Hopkins is a supposedly lower class student of low intellect and a troublesome background, but with a surprisingly adult wit, and so acts as a presence intimidating similar to the four lead kids from South Park, and as immediately likeable. The rest of the cast represent RockStar Games’ fondness of the most grotesque and unsightly of human characteristics as any of the Grand Theft Auto and Manhunt series. Single stereotypes fleshed-out and personified; the drunken bum Santa, the pervert teacher, the unwashed, overweight cook, the ape-like bully and the geek; all imaginable before even a single piece of character art has been shown, and all exactly how many would imagine them.

            Unfortunately, bugs litter the game – speech samples informing you it’s an English Class when the Loading Screen (of which there are far too many) clearly stated it was Maths, Re-Spawning at the wrong Checkpoint, inaccurate control set-up information, sticking points and hilariously bad physics are all common in a brief hour play. The Lock-On System is woefully inaccurate, often resulting in the player hitting their team-mate as opposed to their rival – and occasionally failing the Mission because of it.

Bully: Scholarship Edition remains decidedly last-generation in its’ looks. Having hoped that the sight of Dynasty Warriors finally shifting shape was the sign of the end of direct PlayStation2 ports, it’s unfortunate that a little more care hasn’t been paid to the often jerky frame-rate and glitchy, rough textures. The Character Models are all very-Electronic Theatre Imagewell realised, yet already look very dated. The soundtrack however, is excellent. Although it also is full of glitches and can be quite repetitive, it is brimming with hilarious one-liners and some of the best scripted interactions in videogames.

Bully: Scholarship Edition is a direct port of a game from a previous generation of videogame consoles, and one that hasn’t aged well. There are many elements of the title that disappoint and many that it would be thought a company with RockStar Games’ profile would not allow in a final retail version. The gameplay is of a moderately high standard at the best of times, yet always traditional and rarely particularly inventive. In other words, we’ve all seen Bully: Scholarship Edition before. However, what sets it apart is its’ character; it’s perfectly realised world that is more fun to be entertained in than most. It’s a game that confuses from its’ very core; you’ll like it, but you’ll never be quite sure why. The fact that it will have you coming back for more time-and-time-again may just be enough though.

Electronic Theatre Image

Kev J.                                                                                                                                         Reviews Score Table Interpretation.

26/03/08

Check out the current debate on Bully: Scholarship Edition here.

Get the latest Cheats and Tips for Bully: Scholarship Edition here.

Buy Bully: Scholarship Edition here

Return to the Xbox360 In-depth Reviews Archive here.

 

 

Top

Google
 

© Electronic Theatre 2003 - 2008 - email: kjoyce@electronictheatre.co.uk